Gita 1.41
Arjuna Vishada Yoga
अधर्माभिभवात्कृष्ण प्रदुष्यन्ति कुलस्त्रियः । स्त्रीषु दुष्टासु वार्ष्णेय जायते वर्णसङ्करः ॥४१॥
adharmābhibhavāt kṛṣṇa praduṣyanti kula-striyaḥ strīṣu duṣṭāsu vārṣṇeya jāyate varṇa-saṅkaraḥ
In essence: When adharma floods in, all become vulnerable—and Arjuna, trapped in his era's worldview, blames the victims rather than the violators.
A conversation between a seeker and guide to help you feel this verse deeply
Sadhak-Guru Dialogue
Sadhak: "Guru ji, I have to be honest—this verse disturbs me. It seems to blame women and justify caste discrimination. How can this be in a sacred text?"
Guru: "Your discomfort is appropriate. Never turn off your moral intuition, even when reading scripture. But let us look more carefully. Who is speaking here?"
Sadhak: "Arjuna."
Guru: "Exactly. Not Krishna. Not the divine voice. A human warrior, terrified, searching desperately for reasons not to fight. Does the Gita endorse everything Arjuna says?"
Sadhak: "No, I suppose not. The whole text is about correcting his confusion."
Guru: "Correct. Arjuna represents the conditioned human mind—with all its culturally acquired beliefs, biases, and fears. The Gita includes his words not to endorse them but to show us our own minds. Have you never made a weak argument to avoid something difficult?"
Sadhak: "Many times. But why does Krishna not correct this specifically?"
Guru: "What do you do when someone you love makes an argument so flawed that engaging with it would dignify it? You might stay silent, knowing that a completely different perspective is needed. Krishna's silence on this verse is instructive."
Sadhak: "But people have used this verse for centuries to control women and enforce caste."
Guru: "And they misread it. Notice: 'adharmābhibhavāt'—from the predominance of adharma. What causes women to be 'praduṣyanti'? Adharma. In war, who commits adharma against women? Men. The verse, read carefully, is about women as victims of adharma, not perpetrators."
Sadhak: "That is a very different reading than I have heard."
Guru: "Texts are filters—we see in them what we bring to them. Those who wish to control will find justification. Those who seek liberation will find liberation. The question is not what the text says but what you do with it."
Sadhak: "What about varna-sankara? Isn't that clearly about caste?"
Guru: "In its original meaning, varna referred to one's qualities and tendencies, not birth. Sankara means mixture or confusion. Varna-sankara means confusion of roles, people doing what they are not suited for because natural order has broken down. It is only later interpretation that hardened this into hereditary caste. The Gita itself, in Chapter 4, says Krishna created the four varnas according to guna and karma—qualities and actions, not birth."
Sadhak: "So should I just ignore this verse?"
Guru: "Ignore nothing, but understand everything in context. This verse shows Arjuna's mind in crisis, grasping at every argument. It shows us how we all rationalize our fears. And it shows, by Krishna's pointed silence, that some arguments are beneath refutation."
Did this resonate with you? Share it with someone who needs to hear this.
🌅 Daily Practice
Reflect on arguments you have made to avoid difficult duties. Were they genuine concerns or rationalizations for fear? Arjuna's elaborate social reasoning is ultimately about avoiding personal pain. Notice this pattern in yourself without judgment.
When you hear someone making an argument that seems off but you cannot pinpoint why, consider: is engaging with their specific points useful, or would it be better to reframe the entire conversation? Sometimes the wise response is silence followed by a complete shift in perspective.
Consider how cultural conditioning shapes your own views. What beliefs do you hold simply because you were raised with them? Tonight, question one assumption about how society should be organized. You need not change it—just examine where it came from.