There is Only Brahman
A conversation between Ribhu and Nidagha
Context
Nidagha returns to Ribhu after contemplating the first teaching. His mind still seeks to grasp Brahman as an object of knowledge. Ribhu proceeds to demolish all conceptual frameworks about the nature of reality.
The Dialogue
Nidagha prostrated before his master and said: "O Ribhu, I have contemplated your words. I understand that the seeker and the sought are one. But now I wish to know: What exactly is Brahman? Describe its nature to me so that I may meditate upon it."
Ribhu regarded his student with infinite patience. "You ask me to describe Brahman. Very well. Listen carefully, for I shall describe it by negation."
"Brahman is not the bodyânot this gross form of flesh, blood, and bone that decays and dies. Brahman is not the sensesânot these instruments that perceive a world of apparent multiplicity. Brahman is not the mindânot this stream of thoughts, memories, and imaginings. Brahman is not the intellectânot this faculty that discriminates and judges."
Nidagha nodded. "Then Brahman is beyond all these?"
"Listen further," Ribhu continued. "Brahman is not spaceâfor space is perceived and has limits. Brahman is not timeâfor time arises within Brahman and dissolves within it. Brahman is not the voidâfor the void is merely the absence of objects, and Brahman is not defined by the presence or absence of anything."
"Master, you tell me what Brahman is not. But what IS Brahman?"
Ribhu's eyes blazed with intensity. "Brahman is pure Existence. Not existence as opposed to non-existence, but Existence itselfâthe very fact that anything IS. Brahman is pure Consciousness. Not consciousness as opposed to unconsciousness, but the Awareness in which all knowing and not-knowing appear. Brahman is pure Bliss. Not happiness as opposed to sorrow, but the fullness that remains when all seeking ceases."
"Sat-Chit-Ananda," Nidagha whispered. "Existence-Consciousness-Bliss."
"But even these are only pointers!" Ribhu exclaimed. "Do not make them into concepts to be grasped. Brahman is not a thing with qualities. When we say Brahman is Existence, we mean there is nothing outside Brahman that could exist or not exist. When we say Brahman is Consciousness, we mean there is no awareness apart from Brahman that could be conscious of it. When we say Brahman is Bliss, we mean the end of all seeking, the peace of recognizing there was never anything lacking."
Nidagha pressed further: "But Master, if there is only Brahman, what of this world I perceive? The trees, the mountains, the rivers, other beingsâare they illusions?"
"Illusion is also too strong a word," Ribhu replied. "The world is not nothingâit appears. But what appears? Look at a pot of clay. Is the pot something other than clay? The pot has form, name, functionâbut its substance is only clay. Similarly, this entire universe of names and forms has appearedâbut its substance is only Brahman."
"So the world is real as Brahman but unreal as a separate entity?"
"Now you begin to see," Ribhu said approvingly. "The snake seen in the rope is neither fully real nor fully unreal. It appearedâthat appearance cannot be denied. But upon investigation, only the rope is found. The snake was never there as a snake. Similarly, investigate this world and you will find only Brahman. The world was never there as a worldâonly as Brahman appearing as world."
"Then there is only Brahman," Nidagha said slowly, the truth beginning to dawn.
"There is only Brahman," Ribhu confirmed. "Not 'Brahman and the world.' Not 'Brahman behind the world.' Not 'Brahman pervading the world.' Simply: Brahman. One without a second. Without inside or outside. Without before or after. The fullness that cannot be added to or diminished. You are That. I am That. This conversation is That. The space between us is That. The silence within the words is That. All is Brahman, and Brahman alone is."
⨠Key Lesson
Brahman cannot be grasped as an object of knowledge because it is the subject of all knowing. Through negation (neti neti) we remove false identifications, and through affirmation (Sat-Chit-Ananda) we point to the indescribable reality that remains when all concepts are transcended.